Challenges and lessons in implementing resultsbased. Define them at different levels, including outputs, outcomes and impact. Resultsbased budgeting rbb is a strategic management tool that assists in improving resource management and public sector accountability. Resultsbased management in the united nations development system a report prepared for the united nations department of economic and social affairs for the 2016 quadrennial comprehensive policy.
The article focuses on the introduction of the new concept of resultsbased management rbm in zimbabwes public sector. Results based budgeting rbb is a strategic management tool that assists in improving resource management and public sector accountability. It guides you through the various processes and makes recommendations on how best to apply this approach in the field. Pdf implementing resultsbased management systems in. We work closely with the government where the inputs based monitoring is still the norm and the focus on results based monitoring and evaluation is very limited.
Pdf challenges and lessons in implementing resultsbased. I work for a newborn care health project which aims at contributing towards the millennium development goal 4 i. Considered a key management approach, resultsbased management rbm is a core staff skill everyone in unicef should acquire. Challenges and lessons in implementing resultsbased management. Effectiveness of result based management as a performance management tool evidence from small and medium enterprises smes in zimbabwe. According to madhekeni 2012 in zimbabwe, the resultbased management system has been operational since the year 2005, and in 2010 the system was then introduced in the education sector. Identify problems, assess our assumptions, agree on what changes are necessary, clarify our thinking on the most productive activities, match our interventions to our resources, identify and manage risks, document and then report on results. Results based management is defined in this study as management strategies in individual organizations of the united nations system based on managing for the achievement of intended organizational results by integrating a results philosophy and principles into all aspects of. Four years after the program inception, reports of low vitamin.
The government of zimbabwe issued the results based management rbm policy guidance circular in may 2005 opcgeneral letter no. Cedil the centre of excellence for development impact and. As a result, considerable experience has been gained in a wide range of settings in resultsbased management rbm. Farai mutambatuwisi1, mapira 2nyasha, chakanaka ernest muchadenyika2 and muzvidziwa rutendo faith2 1uzumba maramba pfungwe rural district council, zimbabwe. The research sought to assess the effectiveness of result based management as a performance management tool among small to medium enterprises in zimbabwe. Over 900 health facilities trained in data management,000 more women receiving antenatal care services per year improving health outcomes using results based financing rbf crown agents is implementing the rbf programme, in partnership with the ministry of health and child care mohcc, in 42 rural districts in zimbabwe since 2014. Challenges and lessons in implementing results based management. Results based management rbm is a tool for monitoring and managing the implementation of strategy favoured particularly by organisations and agencies that are part of or are linked to the united nations. A simple explanation is that rbm is a broad management strategy aimed at changing the way institutions operate, with improving delivery and performance i. Resultsbased management in the united nations development system.
This background is expressed in the government of zimbabwe s resultsbased management programme a document prepared by a malaysian consultant. The cornerstone of the rbb is its detailed focus on performance measurement and its linkages with policymaking and resource management. International journal of trend in research and development. However, the transition to a resultsbased culture is a long and difficult process which requires new attitudes and practices to be adopted and, often, staff capacities to be increased. Zimbabwe tracquilister shangahaidonhi department of human resource management, midlands state university, zimbabwe.
It has significant implications for strategic planning, monitoring and evaluation. Pdf use of result based management rbm framework for. Rbm is a participatory and teambased management approach to programme planning hat focuses on performance and achieving results and impacts. As envisaged, the study resulted in the development of the three phased zimbabwe resultsbased management practical model zrbmpm. These performancedriven management systems have confusingly been given various names, including performancebased management, strategic management, and resultsbased management. Results based management, monitoring and evaluation at giz there are a number of documents produced by giz over the past 7 years, outlining slightly varying approaches to describing results.
Results based management rbm can mean different things to different peopleorganizations. Strengthening the implementation of the integrated results based management system in zimbabwe zimbabwes development trajectory is guided by the blue print known as the zimbabwe agenda for sustainable socioeconomic transformation zim asset. Resultsbased management is a broad performance management strategy that has been increasingly adopted by institutional donors over the past decade. Zimbabwe in its 2016 national budget stated that by 2018 all ministries and departments would.
Zimbabwe is implementing a result based financing program since 2011, which was designed to improve utilization of maternal and child health services offered by public health facilities. Implementing resultsbased management in the public sector. This article outlines the two major models of rbm, that is, the integrated resultsbased management system. The first phase addresses rbm implementing challenges and the second phase focusses on incentivising staff to promote the effective implementation of results management. Essence of resultsbased management in zimbabwe posted on october 23. The study investigated the benefits from rbm, problems being encountered and lessons from experience. This document is based on the unesco results based programming, management and monitoring rbm guiding principles, unesco paris, bureau of strategic planning, january 2008, and translated into russian by the unesco cluster office in almaty 5 2. Resultsbased budgeting forms part of broader effort by the government of zimbabwe to introduce resultsbased management across the public services and to improve public financial management in general.
The handbook on monitoring and evaluating for results, a d d r e s s e s the monitoring and evaluation of development. The ongoing support given to ngos by international and national donors can be seen as evidence. Results based management provides managers with a framework to do 8 things. Results based budgeting forms part of broader effort by the government of zimbabwe to introduce results based management across the public services and to improve public financial management in general. Rbm is a performance management approach that is aimed at achieving the organizations bottom. Pdf the importance of result based management rbm and. Resultsbased management rbm, which has been implemented successfully in the public sector in many developed countries, is a relatively new concept in developing countries.
It describes the various components of rbm and project cycle management and explains how to integrate and institutionalize them in field practice. Definitions, purposes and principles of rbm academics and practitioners have interchangeably used diverse terminologies to indicate results management such as rbm, managing for development results mfdr and performance management kang, 2012. As a contribution to the debate over the role of performance. The consistent use of rbm enables us to reach the most disadvantaged children and to report these results regularly to our stakeholders.
Contains a photo and video illustrating the process. Essence of resultsbased management in zimbabwe the. The rbm system across the world over has been triggered. The result based monitoringrbm and use of kpis has been the buzzword in project management these days. According to madhekeni 2012 in zimbabwe, the result based management system has been operational since the year 2005, and in 2010 the system was then introduced in the education sector.
Therefore, the aim of this research study is to investigate and understand the importance of the result based management rbm in the project management and the challenges non governmental organisations coordinating council ngocc. The major tenets of rbm are explored and examined against traditional implementationfocused public management systems. The rbm system focuses the public sector agencies including the. Brief historical background as such, the concept of rbm is not really new. Align individual roles and targets with depeds direction. This marked the fervent commitment to improve performance in service delivery in zimbabwe. The transition the difference between rbm and the preceding era of implementationbased systems lies in the scope, foci and loci of public sector management.
The legislations and policies exist for solid waste management but enforcement of the bylaws was found to be very weak leading to illegal waste management practices. Resultsbased management 2002 223 notes 230 references 231 useful web sites 235 additional reading 236 index 239 boxes i. The integrated results based management is a methodologytool that is being used by the government to reform and modernize the entire public sector central government, parastatals and state enterprises as well as local authorities. Four years after the program inception, reports of low vitamin a coverage and, high home deliveries are common. Performance management is a systematic approach for continuous and consistent work improvement and individual growth. Contains a photo and video illustrating the process in a humorous way. All the programs are accompanied by rigorous impact evaluations. Track accomplishments against objectives to determine appropriate. Zvavahera national university of science and technology, zimbabwe abstract this study sought to evaluate the effectiveness of the results based management. Research concluded that waste management problems in harare municipality are caused by poor enforcement of policies and by laws. As a result, considerable experience has been gained in a wide range of settings in results based management rbm. Over 900 health facilities trained in data management,000 more women receiving antenatal care services per year improving health outcomes using resultsbased financing rbf crown agents is implementing the rbf programme, in partnership with the ministry of health and child care mohcc, in 42 rural districts in zimbabwe since 2014. This document is based on the unesco resultsbased programming, management and monitoring rbm guiding principles, unesco paris, bureau of strategic planning, january 2008, and translated into russian by the unesco cluster office in almaty 8 4. People management issues by robert mandeya a resultsbased management rbm system is a powerful tool that can be used to help policymakers and decisionmakers track progress and demonstrate the impact of a given policy, programme or project.
The role of human resource managers in results based. The blue print is underpinned by the integrated results based management irbm system. However, the transition to a results based culture is a long and difficult process which requires new attitudes and practices to be adopted and, often, staff capacities to be increased. 2 introducing a resultsbased approach aims to improve management effectiveness and accountability by defining realistic expected.
It has a strong focus on the results from operations. Results based management zimbabwe government portal. Based management rbm and its application in programme project management. Resultsbased management seeks to place the measurement of results at the heart of management. The objective of rbm is to provide a coherent framework for strategic planning and management based on learning and accountability in a decentralised environment. Implementing resultsbased management systems in zimbabwe. Resultsbased management is the technique most commonly used by donors and the ngo sector to assess programme effectiveness. Challenges and lessons in implementing resultsbased management article pdf available in evaluation 1.
What are the objectives of the resultsbased performance management system. An evaluation of the effectiveness, page 1 an evaluation of the effectiveness of performance management systems on service delivery in the zimbabwean civil service p. Many of the key challenges are organizational challenges rather than technical. This background is expressed in the government of zimbabwes resultsbased management programme a document prepared by a malaysian consultant. Oct 23, 2015 people management issues by robert mandeya.
Identify clear and measurable results ie what a project aims to achieve. Results based financing for healthcare in zimbabwe crown agents. Results based financing for healthcare in zimbabwe crown. Links with existing tools reminder of definitions rbb is one of a range of public policy management tools. Nhema2 abstract programme based budgeting uses the budget as a tool for making public management more resultsfocussed.
Hence, the topic, the impact of results based management on public service delivery in zimbabwe a case study of. Zimbabwes experience with a resultsbased management programme has also been examined against global experiences from other countries. The research was carried out in the form of a case study in which a sample of 290 employees from a. What is wrong with results based management humentum. Results based management in the united nations development system a report prepared for the united nations department of economic and social affairs for the 2016 quadrennial comprehensive policy. The paper argues that implementing results based management type initiatives is difficult because to do so impacts throughout an organization. An evaluation of the effectiveness of performance management. Resultsbased management is defined in this study as management strategies in individual organizations of the united nations system based on managing for the achievement of intended organizational results by integrating a results philosophy and principles into all aspects of management and, most significantly, by integrating evidence and. One of the specific responsibilities of the bureau of strategic planning is the implementation of the principles of the resultsbased management rbm approach in programming, monitoring and reporting. Resultsbased programming, management and monitoring. A results based management rbm system is a powerful tool that can be used to help policymakers and decisionmakers track progress and demonstrate the impact of a given policy, programme or project. Nongovernmental organisations ngos are generally considered to be playing an increasingly important role in international and national development. Figure 1 shows the scale of rbf programs in africa in 20.
Implementing resultsbased management in local government. Documentary search and field research revealed that in addition to some epochs of progress the politics of administration, forces of patronclientelism and rampant administrative and technical incapacity have. Resultsbased management provides managers with a framework to do 8 things. Hence, the topic, the impact of results based management on public service delivery in zimbabwe a case study of bindura. Nhema2 abstract programmebased budgeting uses the budget as a tool for making public management more resultsfocussed. It in many respects is similar to the logical framework, a strategy implementation tool used extensively by nongovernmental organizations. The impact of resultsbased management on public service. The objective of the study was to establish the impact effect of the results based management system of appraisal where others before it had failed. Implementing resultsbased management in the public.
A resultsbased management rbm system is a powerful tool that can be used to help policymakers and decisionmakers track progress and demonstrate the impact of a given policy, programme or project. The paper argues that implementing resultsbased managementtype initiatives is difficult because to do so impacts throughout an organization. In some the sequence appears to be a standard version of the oecddac results chain as described in a 2017 oecd synthesis of donor results based management. Results based performance management system rpms frequently. The zimbabwe reconstruction fund, under its window of systems reconstruction and development, is also supporting the office of the president. Zimbabwe s experience with a results based management programme has also been examined against global experiences from other countries.
751 228 1038 492 1056 972 421 1126 487 1441 1004 144 744 1433 149 1332 328 785 1169 1502 1258 815 347 130 1350 726 1436 1371